Reviews

Best AI Music Generators in 2024: We Tested Them All

August 22, 2024 4 min read

Best AI Music Generators in 2024

AI can write music now. Not just beats—full songs with vocals.

We tested the major platforms. Here’s what works.

The Big Picture

AI music has gotten good. Surprisingly good. You can generate a complete song—lyrics, melody, vocals, production—in seconds.

Is it replacing musicians? No. Is it useful? Absolutely.

Top AI Music Generators

Suno — Best Overall

What it does: Full song generation from text prompts

How it works:

  1. Describe what you want (genre, mood, topic)
  2. Or paste lyrics
  3. Suno generates a complete song with vocals

Quality: Impressive. Production quality rivals amateur releases.

Best for: Complete songs, lyrical content, trying ideas quickly

Pricing:

  • Free: 50 songs/month
  • Pro: $10/month (500 songs)
  • Premier: $30/month (2000 songs)

Our rating: 9/10

Udio — Best Audio Quality

What it does: High-fidelity music generation

Standout features:

  • Better audio quality than Suno
  • More controllable generation
  • Extension feature for longer songs

Quality: The best pure audio quality we’ve heard from AI

Best for: When audio fidelity matters most

Pricing: Similar tier structure to Suno

Our rating: 8.5/10

AIVA — Best for Composition

What it does: Instrumental composition, especially classical/orchestral

Best for:

  • Film/video scoring
  • Classical-style composition
  • Background music

Not for: Songs with vocals

Pricing: Free tier, $11-33/month paid

Our rating: 7.5/10

Soundraw — Best for Commercial Use

What it does: Customizable royalty-free music

How it works:

  • Generate tracks
  • Customize length, mood, instruments
  • Clear licensing for commercial use

Best for: YouTube creators, podcasters, businesses

Pricing: $17/month

Our rating: 7/10

What We Tested

Pop Song

Prompt: “Upbeat pop song about summer road trips, female vocalist, catchy chorus”

Suno result: Surprisingly radio-ready. Catchy melody, coherent lyrics, polished production.

Udio result: Slightly better audio quality, different style interpretation.

Rock Track

Prompt: “Classic rock song about rebellion, male vocals, guitar solo”

Suno result: Believable rock track. Guitar sounds authentic. Vocals fit the genre.

Lo-Fi Beat

Prompt: “Chill lo-fi hip hop beat for studying”

Both: Excellent. This genre suits AI generation well.

Complex Orchestral

AIVA result: Beautiful composition. Emotional depth. Feels human-composed.

Practical Use Cases

Content Creators

  • Background music for videos
  • Intro/outro themes
  • Mood-setting audio

Best option: Soundraw or Suno (check licensing)

Musicians

  • Idea generation
  • Demo creation
  • Exploring genres

Best option: Suno or Udio

Podcasters

  • Background music
  • Transition sounds
  • Show themes

Best option: Soundraw (clear licensing)

Game Developers

  • Dynamic soundtracks
  • Ambient music
  • Theme variations

Best option: AIVA or Suno

This is important and complicated:

General rules:

  • Most platforms give you rights to commercial use on paid plans
  • Free tiers often have restrictions
  • AI training on copyrighted music is legally contested
  • Check each platform’s current terms

Safe approach:

  • Use paid tiers
  • Keep documentation
  • Check platform terms regularly
  • Consider Soundraw for risk-averse commercial use

Quality Comparison

PlatformAudio QualityVocalsVarietyControl
Suno8/109/109/107/10
Udio9/108/108/108/10
AIVA8/10N/A7/109/10
Soundraw7/10N/A6/108/10

Tips for Better Results

1. Be Specific

“Sad song” → Generic result “Melancholic indie folk ballad about lost love, acoustic guitar and soft female vocals, slow tempo” → Better result

2. Reference Genres

AI understands genre conventions. Use them.

3. Iterate

Generate multiple versions. Pick the best. Regenerate sections you don’t like.

4. Use Lyrics

If you have specific lyrics, provide them. Better than AI-generated lyrics usually.

5. Edit After

Most platforms allow extending, cutting, regenerating sections.

The Reality Check

AI music is good. It’s not replacing professional musicians.

AI is good for:

  • Quick ideas
  • Background music
  • Accessible music creation
  • Inspiration and starting points

AI is not for:

  • Replacing careful composition
  • Unique artistic vision
  • Complex musical narratives
  • Award-winning albums (yet)

Getting Started

  1. Try Suno free — Generate a few songs
  2. Try Udio — Compare results
  3. Find your use case — What do you actually need?
  4. Consider licensing — Match platform to usage
  5. Go paid if needed — Free tiers are limited

AI music is a tool. Like any tool, it’s about how you use it.

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend tools we genuinely believe in.